Revegetation

From the author: I have lost track of how many times I have gone to a drowned batter and heard the following story – over and over. “We put the landscaper on. He did a really good job in the display village so we figured he would be able to do the road cutting.”

Unfortunately, that was an assumption that turned out to be wrong. Much of the seed ended up in the sediment basin; the turf laid on the 2:1 slope was displaced by the first big rain, and so the main contractor has a hold point that cannot be addressed.

While there are some similarities between these two trades, they should not be confused. Bringing the wrong person on board can lead to heavy costs.

Short Version

While a landscaper’s main focus is designing attractive and functional spaces for the convenience of the end users, a revegetation contractor’s goal is to accomplish the stabilisation of a disturbed area and its subsequent self-sustainable condition as a means of ensuring compliance.

One of the jobs is to make things look good. The other is to follow regulation, maintain the environment, and plan for what the weather will do in the next two decades.

Different Jobs, Different End Goals

The difference in make, output, and products has to be taken into account in each profession.

A landscaper will take a blank canvas in the backyard and turn it into a carpet of lawn, garden beds and paved areas with feature trees located strategically. When in a commercial setting, they will develop an office forecourt, shopping centre car park or community space in a townhouse development. The overall look, practicality and maintenance of the finished product are all assessed.

Alternatively a revegetation contractor might be working on newly cut highway batters, pipeline easements running over farmland, creek banks after a culvert upgrade, or mine dumps needing closure. Customers will judge the outcome on the basis of ground cover, erosion stability, plant survival, and approval of the relevant regulator.

People do not love to see a repaired rail embankment, but they only notice it when it does not live up to the expectation.

Expertise and know-how

A good landscaper can identify design principles, hardscaping elements, irrigation, turf, ornamentals, and the finishing details. They can level the site for your retaining wall, lay pavers in a nice herringbone pattern, and make gardens that flower all year long.

By comparison, revegetation professionals understand the science of soils, native plants, erosion, hydrology, seed biology and the various soil factors necessary to establish plants including soil tests for things like sodic clay (that is likely to cause tunnelling). They can identify which native grasses seed in autumn or need summer rain, and which invasives like African lovegrass from a car window.

Both Skill sets take years to master but there is very little crossover between the two.

Soil Preparation

This difference between the two has become apparent in their soil preparation.

Within a house, such a landscaper also places generally enough soil, or buys a garden combination that is spread on the existing substrate. Landscaping isn’t too hard.

On the other hand on a civil site, the revegetation contractor often has to deal with dead subsoil exposed by bulk earthworks. This subsoil has been compacted, is nutrient depleted and can be sodic or acidic. The revegetation contractor needs to soil test, rip where required, apply lime or gypsum if indicated, re-spread the stockpiled topsoil and vary fertiliser rates according to the laboratory analyses. A large volume of garden mix cannot be simply trucked into a five hectare batter and then washed away in the first wet.

Plant Selection

Designers can do plant composition considering the attractiveness, height, screening and privacy, low maintenance, and so on. They usually have to use any exotic plants if it is matching for their design and the customer.

By comparison, revegetation contractors select plants to suit the soil type, climate, slope and project requirements. Many infrastructure and rehabilitation projects require the use of ‘local provenance’ natives, which simply means seed or tubestock collected from the same geographic area. They often include a ‘cover crop’ that is sterile to protect the soil while slower-growing native plants develop underground.

You could have a weed problem and severe erosion in a single year if you established a row of ornamental grasses on a cut batter in the Hunter.

Materials and Gear

Below is a table of common species and equipment used by landscape contractors and revegetation contractors:

LandscaperRevegetation Contractor
Typical plantsAdvanced trees, shrubs, turf rollsSeed mixes, tubestock, cover crops
Ground coverBark mulch, pebbles, turfHydromulch, bonded fiber matrix, jute mesh, erosion blankets
EquipmentBobcats, plate compactors, edgersHydroseeding trucks, drill seeders, water carts, rippers
Hard materialsPavers, sleepers, edging, deckingCoir logs, rock check dams, turf reinforcement mats

There is some overlap, but the primary tools used by each profession vary because of the differences in the work involved.

Erosion Control Integration

Erosion issues are rare when working with landscapers. In a home garden, the ground is relatively flat and there are never huge veins of water flowing through the yard.

Revegetation specialists on the other hand are hard working with erosion problems. In hilly or sensitive areas, revegetation specialists apply erosion blankets, coir logs and mesh to protect soil and seed long enough for root systems to form. They design around drainage lines, sediment basins and the erosion and sedimentation plan for the site. Revegetation specialists understand that without an initial erosion protection system seed often becomes part of the sediment load and is swept away along with your money.

Compliance Responsibilities

Landscaping projects are generally principally responsible to the client, perhaps for conditions of development approval relating to street trees or planting programs.

However, revegetation is monitored by many parties. Perhaps it must comply with environmental protection licenses, council consents, mine rehabilitation plans, road authority standards and vegetative management plans. All have measurable objectives and a revegetation contractor sets photo points, measures cover, survival and reports are subjected to audits.

Writing a monitoring report for the first time would not be a good introduction for a landscaper who has never done one before.

Maintenance and Success Measures

Typical landscaping maintenance might include mowing, pruning, weeding garden beds, adding mulch, and keeping the general property tidy. Success is achieved through the visual appeal of the well-ordered garden, which the owners deem suitable.

By contrast, revegetation maintenance is watering through to establishment, selective control of all declared weed species and environmental weed species, patch seeding, re-fencing from erosion, replacing dead tubestock. A successful revegetation project will have a ground cover of 70 to 80 percent, target plant species based survival rates and stable ground.

A revegetation site which still requires regular mowing after two years is not achieving its purpose.

Where They Overlap

There is some crossover. Planting, mulching, watering and weed control are common activities. Some larger landscaping companies have one or more revegetation divisions that carry out work with trained staff and equipment. Some revegetation crews may also take on softscape work on commercial projects, while both streetscapes and council parks tend to be a combination of the two.

This excess between the two projects is permissible, but make sure that the group working in the work has good knowledge in that type of work. Do not get fooled by the name of the company appearing in the quotation.

Common Misconceptions

Several misconceptions persist regarding the differences between these two professions:

1. “Planting is planting.”. Planting a hedge in a irrigated back garden would not have much in common with holding native plants on a north experiencing growth though without the need of endo.


2. “Hydroseeding is just spray on lawn.” Related to a civil project, it provides an erosion control treatment with a specific mix, mulch rate, and tackifier for a slope.

3. “Plants native to your area need no tending.” False, especially during the first year. They do need watering, weeded, and tended to, just like any other plant.

4. Green means finished. A flush of cover crop growth may occur, but that will not satisfy the requirement as a perennial cover must be in place.

Mistakes Clients Make When Choosing the Wrong Contractor

Clients often make critical errors when selecting contractors:

1. Have a landscaper because they did work of this nature before within the surrounds of the site office.


2. Employing revegetation crew for a landscaping entry statement and then being disappointed with the appearance within the first six months.

3. Pricing by price. The lower rates often do not take into consideration soil analysis, erosion control measures, and maintenance.

4. Not reading the specifications carefully. The contract may specify the use of local provenance seed and monitoring reports and the contractor must be able to supply this.

5. Waiting until a project is well underway to introduce contractors.

How to Select the Right One

Before you sign any documents consider these questions: What defines success for this task and who will approve it? Has this contractor carried out this type of site before? Ask for the site to be photographed twelve months after completion rather than immediately after work. How will the soil be tested and prepared? What erosion control will be in place as vegetation gets established? Who will take responsibility for watering, weed control and maintenance and for how long? Will the contractor keep recording as specified?

Listen carefully to the answers. If a contractor is a professional at this, they should have direct response and if not, it is likely that they will be more concerned about the look.

The Bottom Line

Landscapers improve the aesthetics of the environment for the benefit of humans. Revegetation contractors improve the environment by creating a stable self-sustaining ecosystem in disturbed lands for the long term. Both are skilled trades and having either skill does not automatically qualify someone to be competent in the other area.

Before you even get to the phone, try to determine what the site’s specific needs are. With a site with a slope, a waterway, a compliance target, or regulatory oversight, a revegetation contractor should be contacted. If there’s a front door and client with curb appeal in mind, a landscaper is the better choice. Help yourself by choosing the right contact the first time around and save yourself the cost of second-guessing later on.

Leave a Reply